Section 179 vs. Bonus Depreciation: Two Ways to Write Off Equipment Now

With 100% bonus depreciation restored on a permanent basis and Section 179 limits higher than ever, small businesses now have two overlapping ways to deduct equipment immediately. They sound identical. They’re not — and the differences decide which one (or which mix) your return should use.

What they share

Both let you deduct the full cost of qualifying property — equipment, machinery, computers, furniture, many vehicles, certain building improvements — in the year it’s placed in service, instead of depreciating over years. Placed in service means installed and ready for use, not ordered, not paid for. December purchases sitting in a warehouse deduct next year.

Where they differ

Income limits. Section 179 can’t create or deepen a business loss — the deduction caps at your business income, with the excess carrying forward. Bonus depreciation has no such limit: it can produce a loss that offsets other income (subject to the excess business loss rules at high amounts). A profitable year favors either; a strategic-loss year requires bonus.

Dollar caps. Section 179 has an annual dollar limit (now in the multi-million range, with a phase-out for very large total purchases) plus a specific cap for heavy SUVs. Bonus has no dollar cap at all.

Granularity — the real reason 179 survives. Section 179 is elected asset by asset, in any amount you choose. Bonus applies all-or-nothing per asset class. Want to deduct exactly $60,000 this year and save the rest of the deduction for future higher-bracket years? That’s a 179 move (or a partial-year design your CPA models); bonus can’t do surgical.

State conformity — the New Jersey trap. Many states, New Jersey included, do not follow federal bonus depreciation, and NJ historically limits 179 to a much smaller figure than federal. The result: a big federal write-off with multi-year NJ addback adjustments trailing behind it. Your federal deduction is real, but the state schedule needs to be built correctly from year one — this is among the most common errors on self-prepared NJ business returns.

Used property and eligibility rules differ modestly (both now allow used equipment; 179 covers certain nonresidential roof/HVAC/security improvements that matter to property owners).

How to actually choose

  1. Profitable, moderate purchases: either works — 179 first for control, bonus for the remainder is the standard stack.

  2. Want a loss (to offset a spouse’s W-2, or carry back/forward strategically): bonus.

  3. Expect higher brackets soon (growing business, expiring low-income year): consider electing out of immediate expensing entirely — regular depreciation into 32–37% future brackets can beat a deduction against a 22% year. Immediate is not automatically optimal; it’s a timing choice.

  4. Multi-state operations: model the state addbacks before December, not at filing.

The one-line summary: bonus is the sledgehammer, 179 is the scalpel, and the placed-in-service date is the trigger both share. Decide the mix before year-end while the timing is still yours to control.

Romanchuk CPA LLC is a fully virtual CPA firm serving business owners and individuals nationwide since 2014, with NJ/NY depth. Start with the 5-minute intake form at rfg.tax/start-here.

This article is general information, not tax advice for your specific situation. Figures adjust annually — verify current amounts.